Dutch Biomass Agreement Aims High But Misses the Mark

Scot Quaranda & Adam Macon at the European Commission making the case for Southern forests.

Scot Quaranda & Adam Macon make the case for forests.

After 2 years of negotiations, Dutch NGO’s and Utility Companies agreed on a biomass policy for wood pellets currently burned for electricity. We in the Southern states know all too well that the drastic increase and scale of demand for wood pellets, driven by countries such as the Netherlands, have had devastating effects on forests and communities. This policy agreement, while not everything that the Our Forests Aren’t Fuel campaign demands, is another strong signal that current policies driving the biomass industry expansion are changing, and Southern states need to stop welcoming this industry with open arms. It is another example that our growing movement and direct advocacy to European decision makers is having a big impact.

The policy includes some positive developments. The Dutch agreement focuses on Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) certification. It is important to note that certification is not a substitute for carbon accounting, so while our forests may be better managed, even with FSC, CO2 emissions will continue to rise. That said, FSC is the only forest certification program that is generally accepted by environmental organizations. If less adequate industry standards such as the Sustainable Forestry Initiative (SFI) had been included, we would still have to deal with the worst of the worst practices such as logging of Endangered Forests, conversion of natural forests to pine plantations and the widespread use of toxic chemicals.

Despite industry concerns about the current lack of certified acres, market initiatives like Dogwood Alliance’s paper and packaging campaign have shown that leadership from key industry players and demand from the marketplace can drive increased certification and truly sustainable forestry. Five years ago there was very little, if any, FSC certified forests in the South, and now we have over 4 million certified acres.

While the agreement shows progress for scaling back this destructive industry, it is far from perfect, and we have several concerns.

The timeline for implementing the FSC standards leaves the door open for continued forest destruction for several years. While large tracts of land have to be certified immediately, “smaller” forest plots of under 1,200 acres will not have to seek FSC certification until 2022 or 2023, depending on the start date of the biomass facility. This is especially alarming as it’s been proven by numerous foresters and the US Forest Service that at current rates of extraction, logging and conversion of natural forests to pine plantations will have to increase to meet the wood pellet industry’s growing capacity. Forest conversion is a major cause for concern as 90 -99% of biodiversity is lost when natural forests are converted to pine plantations.

A vast majority of forested land in the South falls under this “smaller” category. This delay period will likely include the entire sourcing areas for the most destructive wood pellet manufacturers, such as Enviva.

Enviva Protest

Citizens protest the Enviva facility in Portsmouth, Virginia.

Biomass policies from European countries must be more aggressive with timelines for adequate sustainability standards; our forests depend on it.

At the rate wood pellet manufacturers are expanding in the Southern states, this 6-7 year gap could spell game over for hundreds of thousands of acres of Southern Forests.

Game over for Southern forests?

Game over for Southern forests?

We commend the Dutch for attempting to address the carbon accounting issue with its policy, but frankly, they missed the mark.

Despite leading science on the issue, the policy fails to incorporate smokestack emissions created by burning forests for fuel and loss of our forest carbon sink. The Dutch policy sticks with outdated EU methodology and only accounts for CO2 emissions in harvest and transport.

Sustainable forestry is not a substitute for accurate carbon accounting.

While we support true sustainable forestry, it does not account for carbon – even FSC acknowledges this.

The policies driving this industry are supposed to increase renewable energy and therefore reduce the amount of carbon in our atmosphere. Burning forests is not a solution to climate change and does not reduce carbon emissions on the timeline necessary to save our planet. If we continue to ignore this root problem, we could potentially reverse all progress that has been made.

Meanwhile, here in the South, the striking conclusion is that wood pellet manufacturing facilities are a bad investment for our Southern states and communities.

The European policies that are driving this industry are changing, sending a strong signal that renewable energy subsidies for wood pellet production (at least in its current state) are no longer guaranteed. Yet, the Southern expansion continues at an unprecedented rate. In fact, new wood pellet manufacturing facilities are being proposed nearly every month, like this one in South Carolina, bringing our total to nearly 40 facilities either proposed or under construction.

When other European countries and the European Union transition to stronger biomass policies (something they have signalled will happen in the next couple of years), the entire demand market for wood pellets will change, leaving behind our local economies as many of these facilities become stranded assets.

We’re providing tax incentives and spending taxpayer dollars to support and welcome an industry that, due to changing policies, might not be relevant in the next 5 years! An industry that uses destructive practices to extract our forests, ship them to Europe, and burn them. Sending our natural flood protection, water purification, critical habitat and beautiful forests up in smoke. What kind of progress is that when truly sustainable solutions exist? It’s time that our local counties and states put the long term health of our economies and communities ahead of pleasing a European appetite for Southern forests.

With the growing controversy around the use of our forests for fuel and policies such as the Netherlands agreement, countries must ask: Is biomass from trees really a viable alternative source of energy? Or are our forests better left standing to do what they do best, sequester carbon?

 

Last week’s editorial “The EPA’s not-so-green emissions plan”  in the Washington Post rightfully asserted that a wholesale switch from coal to wood as a fuel source for generating electricity would take us in the wrong direction on climate change. It would increase carbon emissions at the smokestack, while also degrading forests’ ability to remove and store carbon from the atmosphere.

Standing forests are essential for all life on earth.

Standing forests are essential for all life on earth.

But the note at the end hitting on the importance of policies encouraging the protection of forests as carbon sinks desperately needs more attention in the climate policy arena.

The biomass industry frequently asserts that in the absence of policies encouraging markets that pay landowners to grow and cut trees, forests will be converted to urban development or agriculture. By their logic, we must log and burn trees to protect forests. But as the Washington Post points out, there is another way to value forests; we’re just not doing it.

We must embrace a new path and enact policies to accelerate forest protection through providing incentives and creating new markets that encourage forest landowners to keep forests standing as carbon sinks.

Whether it’s keeping carbon out of the atmosphere, generating abundant and clean drinking water, preventing floods or providing critical habitat for wildlife, the 21st Century demands a renewed and concerted effort to improve forest conservation and protection across large landscapes. We can develop policies that value standing forests for the critical climate, water and wildlife services they provide.

A shift in the way we value forests would go far beyond having positive climate impacts but would result in significantly improved social, economic and environmental outcomes for generations to come.

Kimala enjoying field and forest.

Kimala enjoying field and forest.

Kimala recently joined the Dogwood team as its first ever Marketing Associate. We’re all excited to work with Kimala because of her creative spirit, her marketing experience and her dedication to protecting our Southern forests.

Kimala playing in our forests at a watering hole.

Kimala playing in our forests at a watering hole.

Kimala remembers always being an environmentalist, having grown up in Asheville within a community of folks who were very focused on issues of sustainability, and it shaped the way she views the world. Having spent time as an adult living in New York City, one of the largest metropolitan areas in the world, really reminded her of the importance of being close to nature. She saw the way living in a big city away from nature can increase hostility, isolation and create a fear of being disconnected.  Kimala says,

There’s something about being in nature that allows you to become separate from your problems and see the world more as a whole. I’ve also seen a decrease in my lifetime of the priority to uphold our natural resources, which makes me want to be more involved and active.

That desire to make a difference is what brought her to Dogwood. Kimala followed the organization for quite some time and was inspired by Dogwood’s work and mission. Having gone to school for Culture & Media, Kimala really values the opportunity to use her education and her creativity to serve a greater good through her work to protect our special, wild places and our remaining green spaces. She says,

I feel really lucky to have a job that allows me to be creative and think outside the box, a job that aligns with my core values and helps me achieve an overall goal in my life, which is to be proactive and give back. I feel really lucky to be a part of Dogwood, being part of a team of such hard-working people who are like-minded and mission-driven.

Kimala loves to go on trailruns with groups of people, go for creek walks, collect rocks with gem-like qualities and sit on the edge of overlooks. She loves looking out over nature when as far as the eye can see, there’s nothing but trees, plants and animals.

Kimala also enjoys playing music and trying new cuisines.

Scot Quaranda & Adam Macon at the European Commission making the case for Southern forests.

Scot Quaranda & Adam Macon making the case for our forests.

Over the last several weeks, Dogwood Alliance and our partners had the unique opportunity to directly engage with decision makers in the European Union and within the member states. Delivering them the Our Forests Aren’t Fuel message: that EU energy policies are destroying Southern forests and it’s time these policies change. Over the course of the trip: hustling from meeting to meeting, engaging with officials, delivering our presentation, Communications Director Scot Quaranda and I came to realize an important shift in the way conversation is taking place about the forests we call home. For too many years, the forests of the Southern United States have been sparsely recognized for their incredible contributions to biodiversity, mitigating climate change and improving the health and quality of our communities.

Yet, as they begin to take center stage in the global debate over using our forests for fuel, Southern forests have finally begun to get the recognition they deserve.

We noticed this first in our meeting with a member of the EU parliament, when he described wetland ecosystems of the Southern US as the “North American Amazon”. Wow! We’ll take that. While Southern US wetland ecosystems are vastly different from the Amazon rainforest, it’s still a fact that Southern forests contain the highest tree species diversity in the US and greatest amount of wetland forests in North America.

The growing sentiment is clear: our forests are truly special, and we should do everything we can to protect them.

Ahoskie, NC wood pellet facility, destroying forests for fuel.

Ahoskie, NC wood pellet facility, destroying forests for fuel.

During our second week of travel, we had the unique opportunity to meet directly with British Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change Ed Davey.That we were even able to secure a meeting with Secretary Davey was a huge step forward. As we addressed in our first EU Update blog, it’s become widely understood that the destruction of our forests for the use of electricity was an issue that needs to be addressed. In the meeting, our coalition exposed Secretary Davey to the devastating effects that UK policies are having on the forests, communities and local economies of the Southern US (this past November over 50,000 people sent Secretary Davey SOS messages) and demanded that he take action. While Secretary Davey was clearly moved by our scientific facts and stories from Southern communities, it was clear that he had been lobbied by the industry, making it vital that we continue to communicate the growing opposition movement.

This conversation would have not happened several years ago.

Beautiful wetland forest in the Southern US.

Beautiful wetland forest in the Southern US.

For too long the wood products industry has held a choke hold on the fate of our Southern forests. Our environment and communities have had to deal with the impacts of unsustainable extraction of our native standing forests – our best defense against climate change. That paradigm is shifting. As the native forests of the Southern US continue to gain global recognition, we now have a unique opportunity not only to build the movement that provides lasting protection for our unique forests but helps completely shift the natural resource extraction economy that has suppressed Southern communities and economies for so long. This is an opportunity to transition into a sustainable economy that relies not on the destruction of our precious environment but on the preservation and valuation of the natural world, native culture and truly sustainable industries.

To achieve this vision for our environment and economy, we have a long way to go. But after spending two weeks across the pond, advocating for our unique and important Southern forests and demanding action to protect them, it’s clear that the time is now. We have a growing movement, a unifying issue, and a clear goal.

It’s going to take all of us to achieve success, but I know that our forests aren’t fuel, they’re forests – now let’s fight to keep it that way.

Biomass industry leaders, such as Enviva, try to argue that their increasing demand for our Southern forests is good for forests and will generate forest expansion in the US. We know that this is just not the case. The demand for woody biomass far surpasses anything our natural forests can sustain.

plans are in place to ensure a steady supply of timber in the form of GE loblolly pines.

In an unprecedented and alarming move, the US Department of Agriculture has given GE tree company ArborGen permission to pursue commercial production of a genetically engineered loblolly pine with no regulatory oversight or environmental risk assessment. In the current plan, the potential impacts to the public or to the environment will not be evaluated.

Tell the USDA and ArborGen: No GE Trees

Protest at Tree Biotech Conference 2013. Photo Credit: Global Justice Ecology Project

 

Our native loblolly pines are a key habitat for more than twenty songbirds and other animals, including the endangered red-cockaded woodpecker. If ArborGen’s GE loblolly pines are planted, there will be no way to stop them from irreversibly cross-contaminating native loblolly pines and pine plantations. Loblolly pollen is known to travel long distances. This contamination could take place on private lands and on public lands, threatening some of our last remaining native forests.

The unnatural engineered traits of these trees would lead to unknown and potentially destructive impacts on soils, fungi, insects, wildlife, songbirds and public health.

This decision sets a terrible and unacceptable precedent. If unchallenged, it will allow other GE trees with even more dangerous traits to be developed without any federal or public review. All at a great risk to our natural forests and the habitats they provide.

For too long, profit-seeking industries have sold our native forests for economic gain, transformed them into agricultural tree plantations that in no way resemble natural forests and disregarded the crucial habitat and ecosystem services they provide.

Industries like Enviva and ArborGen attempt to manipulate our forests for their personal gain, and then have the gall to exclude the public, or, worse yet, claim that what they’re doing is actually good for our forests! But we know that just by existing, are forests are doing what they do best.

Our native forests are key to supporting diverse plants and wildlife, maintaining air and water quality, and are our best defense against climate change. Industry attempts to modify our forests for their gains are unacceptable.

But Dogwood Alliance, Global Justice Ecology Project and others are standing up to say no more.

GE Trees arrest resize 600

GJEP and allies protest the Tree Biotechnology 2013. Photo Credit: Global Justice Ecology Project

 

Tell ArborGen that this will not be tolerated. There is a growing movement of anti-GMO groups, forest protection groups, Indigenous Peoples, birders, foresters, farmers, scientists, parents, hikers and many others who do not want our forests contaminated by GE trees.

 Stop this assault on our native forests by taking action now.

US Forest Protection Delegation in front of the Department of Energy & Climate Change

US Forest Protection Delegation in front of the Department of Energy & Climate Change

Dogwood Alliance staff members Adam Macon and Scot Quaranda joined coalition partners Sasha Stashwick from Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and Derb Carter of Southern Environmental Law Center (SELC) to travel as a delegation to Europe to discuss the implication of EU and UK biomass policy on the forests and communities of the Southern US. Thanks to the growing controversy generated by on-the-ground evidence of forest destruction, thousands of Southerners speaking up to protect their communities and forests, and improved carbon science, our message is being heard loud and clear.

On our first delegation to Europe in November 2013, there were big hurdles. We had to combat several myths about the impacts, scale and potential for growth of the wood pellet industry held firm by policy makers. Big companies like Drax, Enviva, and Electrabel had been feeding government officials, decision-makers and the media misinformation and empty rhetoric. Now, just 15 months later, we have proof that our message got through.

Today these decision makers are clear that the use of our forests for fuel is an area of big concern.

We no longer need to debate whether it is just waste wood or residuals; they all understand that the wood pellet industry and utilities are using whole trees.

London

London

The forest carbon debate has come a long way, too, with very few people holding onto the false concept of carbon neutrality. Instead folks are trying to understand the intricacies and how to move forward without destroying more forests and our climate.

Industry myths are crumbling, and hardly anyone still believes that burning wood for electricity is a long-term solution to climate change.

Though this important progress has been made, we still have a long way to go. Bioenergy policies in Europe are still driving forest destruction, and, while new policies are being debated, nothing is certain. The toughest challenges are still ahead.

We’ve clearly upset the balance of power for big utilities and the wood pellet manufacturers.

It appears the US International Pellet Association is responding to our delegation to Europe. They’ve asked their members to write a letter because anti-biomass campaigners (that’s us) are in Europe misleading policy makers. Though they’ve raised the stakes, we doubt they’ll generate over 50,000 letters like our coalition did last November!

Just last week, the US Forest Service released a report about the importance of biomass, claiming that everything was rosy despite the fact that the report itself showed that biomass has increased forest destruction and will likely lead to mass conversion of natural forests to plantations.

It’s been a long first week, but we’ve been energized by our amazing allies here in Europe.

In addition to our meetings with government officials in London and Brussels, some we also attended an inspiring public meeting organized by Biofuelwatch and hosted by Friends of the Earth UK and Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB). 60 people showed up to that event eager learn about how the UK is driving the destruction of Southern forests. We also participated in a major environmental organization gathering that featured 70 people representing 20 countries. This gathering sponsored by Birdlife International, European Environmental Bureau (EEB) and Transport & Environment gave us the opportunity to share stories and strategize.

Thankfully we are ready to meet greater challenges from industry. Over the next 10 days that we’re in Europe, we’ll continue to push. We’ll come home to the Southern US ready to build a stronger campaign to stop the destruction of our forests for electricity.

Clearcut wetland swamps

Clearcut wetland swamps

The US Forest Service’s Southern Research Station released a report assessing the current and potential impact of the rapidly expanding wood pellet export market on the forests of the US South. The South is already the world’s largest manufacturer and exporter of wood pellets as fuel for electricity generation.

The wood pellet industry has plans for exponential expansion over the next several years with most of the pellets exported to Europe to be burned for electricity.

Over the past few years, scientists, local community leaders, river keepers and conservation organizations have sounded the alarm as dozens of new wood pellet export facilities have been constructed and/or announced. Concerns about the impacts have grown with ongoing documentation that the South’s largest wood pellet manufacturer, Enviva, is getting wood from clearcut wetland forests.

This latest report should force policy makers in Europe to pause and rethink the policies that are driving, not only increased smokestack CO2 emissions in Europe, but deforestation across the pond. It should also make our own Environmental Protection Agency think twice about the impact its recently released draft rule regarding forest-based biomass is going to have on one of our most valuable natural resources – standing forests.

Two key findings in the report reinforce what’s at risk if policies continue to encourage the use of wood as a primary alternative fuel source to fossil fuels for generating electricity:

The recent growth in wood pellet exports has in fact resulted in increased logging, and continued expansion in the industry will result in the further expansion of logging.

Wow! Really? All this time the wood pellet industry has claimed that they are simply taking scraps from land that would have been harvested anyway and that they are not causing an increase in logging. I guess we can lay that fallacy to rest now that the US Forest Service has confirmed that, yes, the rapid growth in wood pellet manufacturing is in fact driving increased logging.

The Southern US is lit up red with forest cover loss.

The Southern US is lit up red with forest cover loss.

Global maps of forest cover loss released by National Academy of Science last year show the rapid rate of forest cover loss from logging in the Southern US was four times that of Brazil during the study period from 2000 to 2012. We need to reverse that trend, not accelerate it. The NASA maps and associated report emphasize the need to look beyond mere acres of forests as a measure of sustainability. We must also pay attention to the rate and scale of forest cover loss from logging. When forests are cleared, it takes many years for them to recover, disrupting critical ecological services, including carbon storage.

The growing European appetite for wood as a fuel source will result in more pine plantations across the South.

The US Forest Service report finds that there could be enough wood to supply increasing demand for wood pellets, but that comes at a price – more plantations, and that means the continued conversion of natural stands to plantations requiring  chemical herbicides and fertilizers. It could also mean the industrial use of genetically engineered trees.

Pine plantations are a far cry from natural forests.

The South’s landscape has already been heavily fragmented and degraded by the establishment of fast-growing single species pine plantations, contributing not only to species loss but also to the loss of entire ecosystems, such as the long-leaf pine ecosystem, and to the disruption of entire watersheds, such as the Waccamaw River Basin.

The report also points to the establishment of plantations on “marginal agricultural lands”. This too has important implications for the future as the loss of agricultural lands could drive up food prices, threatening food security.

Whether it’s the expansion of tree plantations in Indonesian rainforests for palm oil or the expansion of pine plantations in the diverse temperate forests of the US South for wood pellets, this form of deforestation is no longer acceptable in the 21st Century. We must get beyond measuring “sustainability” simply by assessing whether we will be able to grow enough trees fast enough to supply an ever-increasing demand.

That definition of “sustainability” is so last century.

The report is also crystal clear in regards to what it does not analyze, and those gaps are worth noting.

  1. The report does not address the greenhouse gas implications of the growth of wood pellet exports to Europe and their effects on Southern Forests.
  2. The report does not assess the ecological impacts associated with the projected change in forest cover.
  3. The model used to predict the growth in forests and plantations was developed with data collected prior to 1997, and the authors of this report note that there are no studies using post-1997 data to support these conclusions.
Atchafalaya Swamp in Louisiana

Atchafalaya Swamp in Louisiana

It’s time to move into the 21st Century and recognize that forests are so much more than the fastest growing trees or the wood they contain! They are homes to countless species of plants and animals. They protect us from storm surges. They remove carbon from the atmosphere. They generate and purify our drinking water. They make life on Earth so much more enjoyable!

Forests are complex living ecosystems that are essential to our long-term survival.

So next time the wood pellet industry touts that they are protecting forests by creating a market that ensures landowners are growing trees, think about what that really means. Think carefully about whether accelerated logging and the further expansion of pine plantations is the direction we need to be going in to sustain life on Earth.

“To effectively address the huge sustainability challenges of the 21st century, we need to restore large expanses of intact natural forest cover across the planet and especially along our coasts. Accelerated logging for wood as fuel is not going to get us there.”

Think hard about whether this is the legacy we want to leave behind for future generations.

Contemplate whether this kind of “yesterday’s” thinking is going to help us solve the sustainability challenges of the 21st Century where climate change, species extinction and water shortages are becoming more evident every day.

There is another way.

New corporate and government policies have the potential to create an economy that encourages landowners to grow forests for carbon sinks, storm protection, biodiversity and water filters. With policies in place that actually incorporate the value of these critical services, we can expand markets and investments that encourage the restoration and maintenance of large expanses of natural forest cover,  bringing much needed balance back to the natural world and ensuring the health and safety of our communities. Our challenge in this decade is to fully embrace new ways of relating to the natural world, letting go of the old paradigms. This latest USFS report is an indicator that we clearly aren’t quite there yet.

We still have some serious work to do.

Let’s hope those with decision-making authority finally start seeing the forest for the trees.

Today, February 2nd is World Wetlands Day. At Dogwood Alliance, we’re taking today to specially recognize the beauty and value of our wetland forests. On this day in particular, we want to share the wonder of wetlands with all our friends and partners.

Awe-inspiring North Carolina Wetlands

Awe-inspiring North Carolina Wetlands

Though many consider wetlands to be uninhabitable swamps, in truth, they are the beating heart of many vital ecosystems. They are biodiverse havens for countless species of animals and plants. They filter our water and air. They protect us from floods. They are homes to many Southern communities.

Wetlands also give us something more intangible; they give us tranquility and adventure. As lifeforms upon this planet and as human beings, these ancient forests take care of us in so many ways.

Dogwood has spent nearly two decades protecting wetland forests from industrial logging. We’ve protected millions of acres by changing the practices of some of the largest corporations in the world. Today we continue that fight against the bioenergy industry, which seeks to clearcut these precious wetland forests, ship them over to Europe and burn them for electricity all in the name of profit. We’re going to put a stop to this absurd excuse for “renewable energy”.

Though we should never forget what we’re fighting to protect, let’s take today to stand in awe of these powerful, majestic wetland forests, to honor all that they do for us and to make a pledge to do our part to preserve them.

solar_panels2Highland Brewing Company is going solar! The company recently released the news that they will be switching over to solar power as a source of energy on sunny days. The company’s Vice President, Leah Ashburn, said,

“There are some tax benefits for installing solar. As a small business in the alcohol industry, we have challenges and pay plenty of taxes. When there are tax benefits that allow us to grow our business while we work toward sustainability, we are in.”

While Highland is committed to greening their beer-making, it’s still a work in progress, so they’ll continue to use regular power when solar isn’t enough. “We have to have reliable power to make beer and run the company,” she said.

We can’t wait to try out our very own beer made with the powers of the sun! It’s research!solar_panels

HighlandBrewery originated in 1994 in downtown Asheville. You can find out more about the wonderful company here.

Outrage Over US Secret Approval of Genetically Engineered Trees

Groups Condemn US for Bowing to Industry, Ignoring Widespread Public Opposition

Plantations are not forests

New York (29 Jan. 2015) ­– Groups from around the world [1] today joined together to denounce the US government for allowing the first genetically engineered tree, a loblolly pine, to be legalized with no government or public oversight, with no assessment of their risks to the public or the environment, and without regard to overwhelming public opposition to GE trees.

A secret letter from the USDA to GE tree company ArborGen [2], dated last August, was recently exposed by scientist Doug Gurian-Sherman of the Center for Food Safety [3]. In this letter, the USDA made the unprecedented decision to allow ArborGen to pursue unregulated commercial cultivation of a loblolly pine genetically engineered for altered wood composition. These trees could be planted anywhere in the US, without public knowledge or access to information about them.

Gurian-Sherman argues the USDA “is deliberately thumbing its nose at the public” with this decision, pointing out that this is probably the biggest environmental regulatory change in the US since the early 1990s [4].

Loblolly pines are native across 14 states throughout the US Southeast, and are grown in plantations around the world. Their pollen is known to travel for hundreds of miles.

“If these GE loblolly pines are released on a large scale in the US, there will be no way to stop them from cross contaminating native loblolly pines,” said biologist Dr. Rachel Smolker of Biofuelwatch. “This is deliberate, irreversible and completely irresponsible contamination of the environment with unknown and possibly devastating consequences. Forest ecosystems are barely understood, and the introduction of trees with genes for modified wood characteristics could have all manner of negative impacts on soils, fungi, insects, wildlife, songbirds, and public health. And all this for short term commercial profit.”

Many are also worried about the international implications of this USDA decision. Winnie Overbeek, International Coordinator of the Uruguay-based World Rainforest Movement states, “We are greatly concerned that these unregulated GE pines could be shipped to Brazil or other countries without public, or maybe even government, knowledge, further promoting the expansion of industrial tree plantations in the Global South. This contributes to deforestation and affects indigenous and peasant communities worldwide who depend on forests for survival.”

Global Justice Ecology Project’s Ruddy Turnstone from Florida remarks, “ArborGen and the government may think they have won this round, but there is already a huge anti-GMO movement. There are also forest protection groups, Indigenous Peoples, birders, foresters, scientists, parents, hikers, and many others who do not want the forests contaminated by GE trees. A great many of them will take action to ensure these trees are never planted.”

In 2013, when the USDA called for public comments on another ArborGen request to commercialize a GE Eucalyptus tree (a decision still pending), they received comments at the rate of 10,000 to one opposing the industry request. By simply refusing to regulate this new GE pine, the USDA has cut the public out of the process completely.  In 2013, a conference on Tree Biotechnology in Asheville, NC was disrupted for its entire 5 days by anti-GE tree activists, and there were multiple arrests.

The Campaign to STOP GE Trees is an international alliance of organizations mobilized to protect forests and biodiversity and to support communities threatened by the dangerous release of genetically engineered trees into the environment. Contacts

Anne Petermann, Coordinator, Campaign to STOP GE Trees:  +1.716.931.5833  (office), +1.716.364.1188 (mobile), [email protected]

Scot Quaranda, Communications Director, Dogwood Alliance: +1.828.251.2525 x18 (office) + 1.828.242.3596 (mobile), [email protected]

Notes 1] The Campaign to STOP GE Trees includes: Biofuelwatch (US & UK), Canadian Biotechnology Action Network, EcoNexus (Europe), Friends of the Earth (Melbourne, Australia), Global Justice Ecology Project (Int’l), Indigenous Environmental Network (North America), World Rainforest Movement (Int’l). Dogwood Alliance is based in North Carolina.

2] A letter dated 28 August 2014 from Michael Firko, Assistant Director of the US Department of Agriculture’s Biotechnology Regulatory Services, to GE tree company ArborGen agreed with ArborGen’s position that their GE loblolly pine did not need to be regulated. This letter was only made public on 13 January 2014. http://www.aphis.usda.gov/biotechnology/downloads/reg_loi/brs_resp_arborgen_loblolly_pine.pdf ArborGen is jointly owned by multinational timber companies International Paper (US), MeadWestvaco (US) and Rubicon (NZ). Most of ArborGen’s executive staff comes from Monsanto. ArborGen attempted to offer an initial public offering of its stock in 2010.  They cancelled at the last minute and records show they lost almost $15 million that year.  Stock value of parent company Rubicon was significantly decreased.

3] “New Genetically Engineered Tree To Avoid Federal Oversight Completely” http://www.centerforfoodsafety.org/press-releases/3713/new-genetically-engineered-tree-to-avoid-federal-oversight-completely

4] “The Next Phase of Genetic Engineering: A Flood of New Crops Evading Environmental Regulation” http://civileats.com/2015/01/27/the-next-phase-of-genetic-engineering-a-flood-of-new-crops-evading-environmental-regulation/

Support Us

Act Now

What’s the most effective way to protect Southern forests? Get involved! We make it easy for you to make a difference.

Join the Movement

Unite with the forests & communities of the South. Be part of the forests, climate, and justice solution.