Ecosystem Services Explained

Guest post by Emma DawsonHave you ever wondered how much a total ecosystem is worth? How much value do trees give us in timber and food? What about air purification and carbon sequestration? How about flood protection, erosion control, or even natural beauty? It’s hard to imagine all the benefits that nature provides humans. These questions are tricky, but the concept of ecosystem services was created to try and answer them. While this idea has some flaws, it can be a useful way to think about our relationship with the natural world. Let’s take a closer look at ecosystem services to try to better understand what they are.

What are ecosystem services?

Ecosystem services are the positive benefits that nature provides to people. These benefits can be big or small. They may be recognized or fly under the radar. Think about a river. It can provide fresh water for drinking, irrigation, and food (by way of fish and other freshwater life). It also may be a fun place to swim or canoe.

Most people can recognize these benefits coming from a river, but there are many others, too. A river can also be important for controlling floods, cycling nutrients, and filtering water. After all, rivers provide a home not only to fish but tons of other critters in aquatic food webs, some of which are so small we can’t even see them. Who knew a river had so many important roles to play?!

4 Types of Ecosystem Services

The benefits nature provides to people tend to be sorted into four classes of ecosystem services:

Provisioning services are the raw materials that nature provides us. These are pretty easy to recognize. They include food, water, timber, fibers, and even medicine.

Regulating services control other natural processes and materials. Bees, butterflies, and birds all help control the growth of plants through pollination. Wetlands help control floods because they act like sponges that soak up extra water. Trees control how much carbon is in the air by storing it. They can also improve air quality by acting like filters.

Supporting services are the most basic natural cycles that nature needs to function. These include the water cycle, photosynthesis, and the cycling of nutrients between organisms and the soil. None of the other services would be possible without supporting services.

Cultural services are the non-material benefits that nature provides people. They are a part of cultures, activities, and the development of who we are. This can include tourism and recreation. It also includes music, art, and stories inspired by nature. Many of the world’s cultures and religions use nature to find meaning for life’s experiences.

What are ecosystem services worth?

Ecosystem services are vital for our wellbeing. However, those making important decisions often ignore or forget about these services. Most examples of ecosystem services are not bought and sold. After all, you don’t go to a forest to buy clean air and water! This can make it hard for services to be taken into account since they don’t have a price. Climate change, deforestation, and other threats are also depleting these services. Without a way to communicate the value of ecosystem services, they may be harmed beyond repair. This is a scary thought because these services are vital for our existence.

there is no planet b protest sign - ecosystem services

To make sure that ecosystem services are recognized, decision-makers and scientists work together to assign them value. This is expressed in dollars. How can we figure out a price for things that we don’t usually pay for? There are several ways:

Avoided cost is the amount of money that people avoid paying because of the ecosystem service. For example, wetlands help to reduce the impact of flooding by soaking up water. This helps avoid millions of dollars of damage that major storms can cause.

Replacement cost is the cost that people would pay if the service did not naturally exist. If wetlands didn’t exist along coastlines, reservoirs and flood control systems would be required to control floods. These are very expensive to build. It costs a lot of money to replace natural systems.

Travel cost is the amount of money people willingly pay in order to travel to use an ecosystem service. This is usually applied to areas such as parks and recreational activities.

Contingent values are a way to understand how much we’re willing to pay to maintain a service. People are presented with hypothetical scenarios where they express how much they would pay to keep or increase a service. This helps determine how much these ecosystem services are valued.

ecosystem services - money growing on a tree

These methods help scientists estimate the value of ecosystem services. Valuations fall across a wide range and are frequently updated. Some scientists say that the value of global ecosystem services is between 16 and 54 trillion US dollars per year! Compare that to the global gross national product, the total value of all of the world’s goods and services, of 18 trillion dollars per year. There is a lot of value in our natural environment, and it is important that we not take it for granted.

What are some drawbacks to using the ecosystem services approach?

While this method is useful for valuing important services, it isn’t perfect. There are many criticisms of the concept that are important to take into account when thinking about ecosystem services.

This method has been criticized as anthropocentric. This means that humans, rather than nature, are at the center. Ecosystem services can be seen as ignoring nature’s intrinsic value. Some argue that nature should be valued for its own sake rather than because humans value it. The ecosystem services concept is utilitarian, defined for practical purposes to be used by people. But some believe that nature should be the central focus and that human use is less important.

Others think that the ecosystem services concept can lead to overexploitation. They think that this allows people to become consumers of nature rather than protectors and stewards. Putting a price on nature’s goods and services means that they can be bought and consumed. This could lead to overconsumption by people who have enough money and resources. This argument holds that we should not put a price on nature because it’s priceless and vital to our survival.

planet over profit - ecosystem services explained

What About Cultural Impacts?

Cultural ecosystem services can be difficult to assign value to. There has been lots of research focused on tourism and recreation because they are easier to price. Cultural services, especially in non-Western contexts, have been neglected in studies. This is especially true of the cultural value of nature in traditional and Indigenous communities.

Different cultures have different relationships with the environment. Many cultures use nature as a central part of identity. Ignoring this diversity does a disservice to these different cultures, especially marginalized and underrepresented groups. I’s very important to understand cultural contexts when using ecosystem services valuation.

Another criticism is that this method ignores important power relationships. Individuals, institutions, and power structures all play a part in determining how ecosystem services are distributed and managed. Simply assigning a dollar value to these services can be seen as an oversimplification.  Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) communities often lack equitable access to ecosystem services. This is typically not reflected in valuations.

Assigning monetary value to nature can also be viewed as imposing Western values on spaces with Indigenous origins. This has been noted as a continuation of Western exploitation of indigenous land and resources without respect for their views. Valuation in itself is an expression of power. It’s important to consider who is benefitting from services, how we can remove barriers that block access, and the historical context behind our valuation of nature.

Want to learn more?

The idea of ecosystem services is complicated but also interesting. There are many different ways it can be used and lots of points to consider.

Check out Dogwood’s report, Treasures of the South, to learn about ecosystem services in wetlands.


emma dawson

Emma Dawson is a rising third year at the University of Virginia and summer intern at Dogwood Alliance. She is currently pursuing a Bachelor of Science degree in Environmental Science, which she hopes to apply to research opportunities in graduate school and beyond. Emma loves watching and playing soccer, cooking, and spending time outdoors with friends and family.

Guest Post By Brianna Cunliffe

There are growing gaps between rural and urban Americans in terms of economic opportunity, access to resources, and political orientation. This is often referred to as a “rural-urban divide”. Americans who rely on the land to make their living have an enormous stake in keeping it healthy for generations. But conversations about conservation and the environment often leave out rural communities. This is one way in which we see the serious problem of the rural-urban divide. In this rapidly-changing world, people from different communities face starkly different challenges. There’s a lack of empathy and dialogue between urban and rural Americans. We can’t pursue solutions together unless we understand one another’s perspectives.

Forests are a bridge between what can seem like two different worlds. A new forest economy can arise based not on extraction, but on protection and innovation. Conservation gives rural communities the opportunity to shape their own destinies and help the planet at the same time.

Shifting Economies in the Rural-Urban Divide

rural rolling hills and farmland

People who work in trades, factories, and on the land see a widening gap between themselves and city-dwelling “elites” – those who work at desks, often with advanced degrees. The farmers, ranchers, and blue-collar workers who have called rural areas home for generations face unprecedented challenges. Traditional economic structures are shifting. Consolidation threatens small family farms. Outsourcing threatens to send towns’ biggest employers overseas. Technology displaces human workers and makes good-paying jobs even harder to find. Meanwhile, popular culture tends to ridicule rather than sympathize with rural challenges, like lack of access to healthcare and education. People are left to face a changing and precarious future alone. All of these things make it hard for rural and urban folks to align on the direction our nation is heading.

Politics in the Rural-Urban Divide

Rural Americans see resources going to big cities while rural communities struggle to make ends meet. Many urban people discount rural people as uneducated and stuck in the past. Politicians exploit these resentments and rifts for their own benefit, worsening things further. Often politicians claim to be on the side of the “little guy” to win votes in struggling communities. But once in office, they sell their constituents out. But, some would say, at least they pay attention to the issues that matter to rural voters.

Unfortunately, other politicians totally ignore large swaths of the country to focus on what they frame as “the future.” They claim that the future is all about cities and technology and leave out rural voices. This ignores the suffering of rural communities and deepens resentment. Already for many rural Americans, it’s difficult to believe in a government that has failed so many for so long.

Extraction in the Rural-Urban Divide

From coal mines to lumber mills, the industries which rural communities rely on have one thing in common: they’re extractive. Because of this, companies get away with treating people like they’re expendable. The logging industry is a prime example. Logging is the second most dangerous job in the world. The average age of workers ranges from 50-60, and health coverage and benefits are subpar at best. Folks in timber towns work until their bodies give out and get no loyalty from the industry in return. The livelihoods of whole communities hang in the balance of international market forces.

a factory emits smoke

Rural Americans deserve better. They deserve fair compensation for their hard work. They shouldn’t have to sacrifice their health or the natural beauty around them to make a living. They deserve the chance to shape their own future and that of their children. A new forest economy can offer this and more.

The Future Forest Economy

A better future requires a shift away from extractive economies. This means phasing out industries that rely on resource extraction, like logging. Replacing these industries with sustainable alternatives has positive consequences in many ways. First, communities would no longer have to endure the boom and bust cycle. In a boom and bust cycle, companies arrive, become a large employer, and leave when business becomes cheaper elsewhere. This pattern devastates entire towns, leaving many unable to provide for their families.

Second, the health of communities would improve. Extractive industries generate harmful pollution that affects large areas. Pollution causes enormous negative health impacts often leading to premature death. It’s not only the chronic long-term issues like higher rates of asthma and cancer. Hazardous and poorly-managed industrial sites can cause devastating fires and catastrophic explosions. One just happened at a wood pellet plant in Brunswick, Georgia. Pollution makes rural communities less desirable places to live, work, and visit. This drives property values down and discourages tourism, limiting growth and suppressing opportunity.

The protection of our forests promises multiplying, cascading benefits for everyone involved. Sequestering carbon in standing  forests will ease the devastation of global climate change. Non-extractive alternatives will improve peoples’ lives and incomes. Tourism, recreation, and research will bring much-needed opportunities to rural communities. This is the new forest economy, and it’s the way to a better future.

Opportunities For Bridging The Rural-Urban Divide

Our leaders need to move to enact these win-win solutions on a large scale. There is no time to waste. Biden’s 30-by-30 goal (a commitment to conserve 30% of land area by 2030) is a good start. But industrial forestry and the dirty biomass industry have accrued too much power. Even those who proclaim to be on the side of conservation, like Governor Cooper, are all too often silent. But corporate interests can’t outweigh the needs of struggling rural communities nationwide.

a road cuts through a dark forest

Protecting forests sends a clear message to rural communities that they matter. Stopping exploitative logging and biomass production opens another path forward. It ends the generations of harm and neglect that have entrapped people in vicious cycles. Because of extractive industries, so many hard-working Americans live in poverty and isolation. They are forced to rely on polluting corporations that cut and run with no warning, leaving entire towns stranded. Holding these industries accountable is the first step to breaking the cycle.

Vibrant, thriving forests nurture thriving communities. Government support for a transition away from extractive industries can right generations of wrongs. Conservation can begin to heal the wounds that divide us. The new forest economy is a bridge to a better future. It starts with bold, courageous action to protect the land we rely on and love.

Ready To Do Something? Tell President Biden To Take Action On Our Forests


Brianna Cunliffe grew up reading books tucked in the branches of a Carolina pine a few miles away from the sea. Now a rising senior Government and Environmental Studies major and department fellow at Bowdoin College, she seeks to blend passionate activism on behalf of the natural world with innovative, justice-centering policy solutions. Brianna previously worked with elected officials on Protect America, organizing state and local leaders to take action to fight the climate crisis. She’s thrilled to join Dogwood Alliance as an intern to work on the issues closest to her home and her heart.

Hurricane Ida made US landfall on Sunday, August 29th as a Category 4 storm directly impacting Southern Louisiana and Mississippi. The destructive winds, devastating flooding, and deluge of rain were a reminder of why we do the work that we do. The climate crisis is accelerating and making storms of this magnitude more frequent and intense. We recognize that this past weekend was also the 16th Anniversary of Hurricane Katrina.

As the Regional Partnership Engagement Manager for Dogwood Alliance, I understand the impact that these recurring natural disasters have on families, communities, and livelihoods.

So many of our partners have families and friends who are suffering the effects of Hurricane Ida, and we stand in peace, solidarity, and love with all communities impacted.

Our work is committed to supporting our frontline partners and the environmental justice communities that continue to face compounded injustices. It takes a community to build where we are broken and not where it’s beneficial for one organization.

hurricane-ida-solidarity-hands-holding

We are in community to build community, and our community needs us!

So, let’s build community. Dogwood Alliance pledges to support the Gulf Coast Center for Law and Policy (GCCLP) Rapid Response Fund led by those at the frontline of recovery to best move resources quickly to the ground.

We challenge other organizations to do the same, and we encourage individuals to donate!

Welcome to Part Three of our four-part forest documentary series. We’ve scoured the land to bring you a curated list of the best forest documentaries! Not sure what to watch this weekend? Don’t worry; we’ve got you covered.

You may ask, “What is an old growth forest?” It’s a forest that has been allowed to grow and mature for a long time, usually at least 100 years. Wow! Unfortunately, old growth forests are vanishing across the planet as logging intensifies. These incredible places are so important for wildlife habitat, water filtration, and the incredible amounts of carbon they can store. Not only that, but they are beautiful and awe-inspiring. Go on a journey with us to visit remarkable old growth forests from all across the world!

The Lost Forest

This National Geographic short documentary features an international team of scientists and explorers who go on an extraordinary mission in Mozambique to reach a forest that no human has set foot in. The team aims to collect data from the forest to help in our understanding of how climate change is affecting our planet. But the forest sits atop a mountain, and to reach it, the team must first climb a sheer 100m wall of rock. Where to watch: Available on YouTube.


Hunting Giants

A wilderness explorer searches for the largest old growth tree still standing near Port Renfrew, Canada, a logging town on the brink of collapse. This cinematic adventure into the old-growth rainforests of British Columbia explores the choices faced by many forest communities: do we remain focused on dwindling timber profits or reinvent ourselves into an outdoor recreation and tourist economy?


When Old Growth Ends

When Old Growth Ends tells a love story about the Tongass National Forest of SE Alaska through the eyes of the salmon, the old-growth trees, the Indigenous peoples, and a group of women with an affinity for wild places. The documentary illuminates how the failing timber industry and its government enablers have ruptured the heart of the Tongass, leaving the last remaining old-growth temperate rainforest in the nation vulnerable to completely unraveling. Where to watch: Available here.


Treeline

We couldn’t say it any better than Patagonia Films does of their feature length documentary:

“Quietly, patiently, trees endure. They are the oldest living beings we come to know during our time on earth. They provide our shelter, our fuel, our companions, and—in some cases—our divinity. They are living bridges into our planet’s enormous past, their obscure stories written into their rings over centuries and even millennia. Treeline takes us to the enshrined cypress groves of Japan, the towering red cedars of British Columbia, and the ancient bristlecones of Nevada, following a handful of skiers, snowboarders, scientists, and healers as they move through these giants and explore a connection older than humanity.”

Where to watch: Available on YouTube


Bury Me in Redwood Country

A documentary about the Redwood forest landscape. A forest where the tallest and largest trees on the planet can be found. The documentary includes interviews with Redwoods experts, foresters, conservationists, Native basket weavers, rangers, and naturalists.


Be sure to check out the others in our 4-part top forest documentaries series:

Part 1: Top 5 Forest Preservation Documentaries Part 2: Top 5 Forest Restoration Documentaries Part 4: Top 5 Communities and Forests Documentaries

Guest post by Emma Dawson

The Southeastern United States is home to a variety of reptile species, some of which you’ve probably seen in real life! In fact, in 2016 the area was named the world’s 36th biodiversity hotspot. Reptiles are an important part of this biodiversity. Lizards, turtles, snakes, and crocodiles are scaly animals that fall into this category. The region is home to over 450 reptilian species and subspecies. About a third of them are endemic – that means they aren’t found anywhere else in the world!

a heat map showing high biodiversity of reptiles in the US South

Sadly some of these critters are losing their homes. Habitat destruction has caused some reptile populations to fall to low levels. Let’s take a closer look at some of these vulnerable species.

Bog Turtle

Blink and you might miss them: bog turtles are the smallest turtles in North America. They’re usually only 4.5 inches long! You can recognize them by the orange patches they have on both sides of their head. They live in mountain bogs and wetlands in the Southern Blue Ridge Mountains of Georgia as well as North and South Carolina. They like to live in areas with wet soil, thick moss, and deep layers of mud, but they also need open, sunny areas for basking and nesting.

a bog turtle rests on a leaf

Only 4,000 to 6,000 individual bog turtles currently live across 100 sites. Habitat loss is a big threat to these little ones with only 10% of mountain bog habitat remaining in Southern Appalachia. These areas are often drained and developed. That limits the ability of turtles to travel through wetland environments. The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) is an organization that maintains a database of the status of species around the world. The IUCN lists bog turtles as critically endangered. That means that they’re threatened with global extinction. The US Fish and Wildlife Service placed bog turtles on the Endangered Species List in 1997, so these turtles and their habitat are protected by the federal government.

Southern Hognose Snake

As its name suggests, you can recognize the Southern hognose snake by its upturned snout and wide neck. They’re easy to confuse with diamondback rattlesnakes. But, unlike its slithering look-a-like, Southern hognose snakes rarely bite. Instead, they may hiss, fake striking, and eventually play dead. This has earned them a variety of nicknames, including hissing adder, blow viper, and several others. These snakes dwell in longleaf pine forests, living in dry, sandy soil where they can burrow underground.

a hognose snake rests in pine needles

The IUCN has listed Southern hognose snakes as vulnerable. While this is not as bad as the critically endangered bog turtles, it still means that these snakes are threatened with global extinction.  In fact, they may be the “rarest and most threatened snakes in North America”. Like bog turtles, Southern hognose snakes suffer from habitat loss with the decline of their longleaf pine habitat. Road mortalities are also common because they sometimes use the hot asphalt to warm themselves. Southern hognose snakes used to live in many states throughout the Southeast, but we haven’t been able to find them in Alabama or Mississippi, their old stomping grounds, since the 1970s. How can we change that? The best things to do are protect pine forest homes and educate folx about how harmless these snakes are.

Florida Sand Skink

At first glance, this gliding critter looks like an ordinary snake. Look again! Florida sand skinks are actually lizards with four small legs that are basically non-functional. This slender reptile is usually grey or brown. They have shiny scales and are only four to five inches long. The coolest thing about these skinks is that they can “sand-swim” a few inches below ground, leaving wave-like patterns at the surface. They’re usually found in sandy areas with shrubby vegetation and bare patches of sand, and they are endemic in central Florida.

The IUCN lists the Florida sand skink as vulnerable, and it is classified as federally threatened. This means that this species might become endangered soon, and the government has given it extra protection. The sandy areas they live in are disappearing. Up to 90% of their scrub ecosystem has been lost to development and agriculture. That’s not ok! We need to protect them! To do that, we’ve got to protect and expand the habitats where they make their homes.

Gopher Tortoise

Like the Florida sand skink, the gopher tortoise enjoys spending time underground. In fact, up to 80% of its life is spent in burrows. These tortoises have stumpy hind feet and flattened shovel-like forelimbs covered with thick scales, which help with digging. Gopher tortoises may only be nine to eleven inches in length, but they play a very big role in their ecosystems. Their burrows serve as shelter to all kinds of other animals, including burrowing owls, mice, snakes, and rabbits. Gopher tortoises share their homes across the South in Georgia, Florida, South Carolina, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Alabama.

The IUCN lists the gopher tortoise as vulnerable. They’re classified as threatened in their western range of Mississippi and Alabama. Their biggest threat is loss of their home habitats of longleaf pine sandhills, scrub, and coastal dunes. Us humans also like to build our houses on the same high, dry land that gopher tortoises inhabit. Phosphate, limestone, and sand mining are also a problem for them in central Florida. When we try to relocate these tortoises to safety, they usually try to make their way back home. These homeward journeys can be very dangerous and lead to road mortalities. The good news is that a plan is already in place to protect these critters! The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission has plans to restore gopher tortoise habitat and increase their numbers in areas where they’ve declined.

How can you help?

You don’t have to be a scientist to help protect these reptiles! Here are some ways you can help out:

You can become a citizen scientist! What does that mean? Citizen science is a way that scientists work with the public to collect data. You can help scientists get the information they need to better understand critters and their homes. HerpMapper is a website that lets you submit your own pictures of reptiles and amphibians that you see in nature. This data is then used for research and can help scientists know where reptiles are living.

You can help to fight climate change! Reptiles are sensitive to changes in our climate. The warming earth can also hurt their habitats. You can help change this by supporting good climate policy and voting for officials who are fighting climate change. You can also reduce your own carbon footprint by using climate-friendly transportation, eating locally grown food, and reducing your electricity use.

And… Action!

Did you enjoy learning about these cool reptiles? If so, why not show us?

Share your favorite reptile photos or videos and tag us on Instagram, Facebook, or Twitter!

Want to do more?

Become a Forest Defender today! Your monthly gift will protect the reptiles and biodiversity of the South.

Join our email list to get new Biodiversity in Your Backyard sent directly to your inbox!

Check out the other blogs in our Backyard Biodiversity series!


emma dawson

Emma Dawson is a rising third year at the University of Virginia and summer intern at Dogwood Alliance. She is currently pursuing a Bachelor of Science degree in Environmental Science, which she hopes to apply to research opportunities in graduate school and beyond. Emma loves watching and playing soccer, cooking, and spending time outdoors with friends and family.

Guest Post By Brianna Cunliffe

North Carolina’s forests are in peril. Governor Cooper and state laws fail to stop destructive logging and dirty bioenergy.  The timber industry claims carbon neutrality, evading accountability for the harms it generates. But across party lines, North Carolinians are getting tired of the greenwashing. Dogwood Alliance asked 1,000 people how they felt about the destruction of our forests. The results were astounding: Our communities have had enough of polluting industries ravaging our precious resources. They’ve had enough of devastating clearcuts, enough of harmful air pollution from wood pellet plants. Enough of policies that ignore science and don’t value forests as complex, living ecosystems instead of just dead timber that turns a buck. Enough of communities being treated like dumping grounds. State leaders must listen to the people speaking out against these harmful industries. The people have clearly expressed that they see far more value in forests as beautiful spaces to recreate than resources to be logged.

Governor Cooper and the state legislature must act to keep their commitment to the people of this state. They must stop the rise of industrial forestry and bioenergy before it’s too late, before our priceless forests vanish forever.

Unchecked Logging

Less than a third of state residents believe that logging laws are adequate in NC. It’s no wonder since the logging industry destroys over 200,000 acres of forest every year. The impacts of industrial forestry aren’t even considered in the state’s records of greenhouse gas emissions.

 7 in 10 residents believe the logging industry should be held accountable for its emissions (71% agree, 16% unsure, 13% disagree).

7 in 10 NC residents believe that the logging industry should be held accountable for its carbon emissions

Yet this key piece of accountability is still missing from North Carolina’s Clean Energy Plan. The US Forest Service has acknowledged that timber harvesting was the largest source of gross emissions from US forests between 2006 and 2010. What’s more logging is the biggest driver of forest carbon loss in the US. That’s five times more than the carbon storage lost from development, agriculture, and fire combined. These problems are critical in North Carolina where logging from the wood pellet sector alone destroys 164 acres of forest each day.

An industry-skewed accounting system obscures harmful emissions by confusing this destruction with questionable claims of carbon benefits from “industrial forests”. Although the logging industry claims to replace the trees they cut, this practice doesn’t solve the problem of lost carbon storage. These tree plantations store 50% less carbon than our irreplaceable natural forests. The timber industry cuts down thriving ecosystems to produce short-lived wood products that will soon end up in landfills. Over 85% of carbon from all wood products, including lumber, is in the atmosphere within 100 years. A majority of North Carolinians believe we should stop supporting industrial pine plantations at the expense of natural forests (17% keep subsidizing, 32% unsure, 51% stop).

A majority of NC residents believe we should stop supporting industry expansion into natural forests.

So why are we still subsidizing this harmful industry? Why won’t the state government tell us about the emissions coming from the forestry industry and hold them accountable?

Logging doesn’t just harm communities who live near the devastation of clearcuts. The destruction of our forests also harms state-wide air quality and hurts resilience. The more trees the timber industry cuts down, the more vulnerable our communities are to disasters like hurricanes and floods. Young North Carolinians, who fear the future impacts of climate change, are demanding change: 4 out of 5 young adults agree that logging makes matters worse (78%, no break-down for neutral/disagree).

4 out of 5 young adults agree that logging makes matters worse

There’s no partisan divide on this issue, either. 7 out of 10 conservatives believe that logging is harmful to forests, climate, and communities, just like those who lean liberal (94% of liberals, 86% of moderates, and 69% of conservatives).

7 out of 10 conservatives believe that logging is harmful forests and the climate.

No matter your political identification, it’s clear that our forests are critical. They nourish the air we breathe, the water we drink, the places we recreate, and the communities we call home. But traditional logging isn’t the only threat our forests face. The rise of bioenergy, which burns wood pellets to generate electricity, risks making the destruction even worse.

Forests, Not Fuel: Dirty Bioenergy Isn’t Fooling Anyone

Even as they burn our forests and pollute our vulnerable communities, bioenergy giants like Enviva claim that they “grow more trees” to “fight climate change”. But even without a public debate on the matter, North Carolinians aren’t buying it. Only 1 in 4 residents believe that dirty bioenergy should be considered carbon neutral (26% agree, 26% unsure, 47% disagree). They’re listening to scientists, who agree that biomass from forests actually produces higher carbon emissions compared to fossil fuels. Yet the industry receives handouts and subsidies as if it were a true renewable like solar or wind.

Just one in four residents believe that dirty bioenergy should be considered carbon neutral

Enviva is even set to expand into a fifth facility without being held accountable for the damage it’s already done. In Lumberton, NC,  90% of the 1250+ comments made by community members opposed a new polluting wood pellet plant. Yet for some reason, the NC Department of Air Quality still approved its permit. Decisions like these override the protests of frontline leaders and go against the will of the people who continue to question, “Where’s Cooper?“

The destruction of our forests doesn’t even truly benefit working people. 20% of jobs in the wood manufacturing industry vanished in the late 2000s because of mechanization and decline in demand. Sudden plant closures, devastating clearcuts, and worsening pollution restrict community economic growth. Climate-driven disasters like hurricanes and droughts will only cause more devastation.

Why won’t Governor Cooper act? He can stop the expansion of dirty biomass and hold the logging industry accountable. As the state fights to achieve its clean energy goals, forest protection is a crucial missing piece of the puzzle.  Over ⅔ of citizens favor stronger restrictions, so why wait any longer? (66% in favor, 17% unsure, 16% oppose)

Two thirs of citizens favor stronger restrictions on the logging industry.

Standing Forests

North Carolinians believe scientists: the best thing forests can do for our future is stay standing. Forests are our most precious resource for carbon storage and biodiversity. Their natural beauty guards our health and resilience and makes our state special. When they’re protected, they can flourish, and we will all breathe easier.

Download The NC Polling Infographics


Brianna Cunliffe grew up reading books tucked in the branches of a Carolina pine a few miles away from the sea. Now a rising senior Government and Environmental Studies major and department fellow at Bowdoin College, she seeks to blend passionate activism on behalf of the natural world with innovative, justice-centering policy solutions. Brianna previously worked with elected officials on Protect America, organizing state and local leaders to take action to fight the climate crisis. She’s thrilled to join Dogwood Alliance as an intern to work on the issues closest to her home and her heart.

A Podcast Interview with the hosts, Elizabeth Lashay, Erniko Brown, and Kimala Luna.

This week we flip the script as Chaya Brennan Agarwal interviews the hosts of Woods & Wilds: The Podcast, Erniko Brown & Kimala Luna from Dogwood Alliance and Elizabeth Lashay from SlayTheMic, about their connection to nature, motivation, and staying connected to the work.Chaya Brennan Agarwal is a rising third-year undergraduate at Duke University from Los Angeles, California, majoring in International Comparative Studies. She is passionate about climate justice and raising awareness of environmental issues through documentary arts, especially photography and painting. She is the Marketing and Communications Intern at Dogwood Alliance.


Join Dogwood Alliance and SlayTheMic as we bring you tales of connection to nature and music.

The Hosts

Listen to the full Woods & Wilds: The Podcast featuring The Hosts:

Want to listen to more?

Check out other episodes of Woods & Wilds: The Podcast


Don’t forget to like, follow, subscribe, or leave a review on your favorite podcast platform. It helps us grow our audience.


Read the full transcript of our interview with Elizabeth Lashay, Erniko Brown, and Kimala Luna!

Full Transcript featuring The Hosts:

Elizabeth Lashay: All right. Well, hello everyone. I’m Elizabeth Lashay from Slay The Mic, and I’m joined by my wonderful cohosts.

Erniko Brown: Well, I am Erniko from Dogwood Alliance, one of the amazing co-hosts, and our next co-host is:

Kimala Luna: I’m Kimala Luna, also with Dogwood Alliance, and today, we are introducing a special guest. This is Chaya Brennan Agarwal, who is a rising third-year undergraduate at Duke University from Los Angeles, California, majoring in international comparative studies. She is passionate about climate justice and raising awareness of environmental issues through documentary arts, especially photography and painting. She is the marketing and communications intern this summer at Dogwood Alliance, and this week, we are flipping the script and Chaya will be interviewing us so that we can tell you a little bit more about who brings you this podcast each time. Hi Chaya.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Hi everyone. So to start, Erniko, I had a question for you. Why did you decide to run for a public office, and how has it been to hold this position?

Erniko Brown: Oh wow. Who told you that information, because I didn’t say that. But no, seriously, what made me run was the fact that we are… Well, Black people aren’t historically at the table, and I also felt like it was a very unique position to be in, as in that position is historically held by older white people. And so I wanted to make it a place where people see the possibility and access and that it’s not enough to organize around issues. We have to have a seat at the table. If we have a seat at the table, then it’s possible to create that change that we want to see in our communities.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Yeah, that’s amazing. And this is a question for you all. When did you first feel a connection to nature and to the forest?

Elizabeth Lashay: That’s a great question. I think I really started to have a deeper connection after some traumatic experiences, and it really made me realize how much I needed the outdoors in order to heal. And so I would really have to say it was whenever I was 22 and I felt like the world was kind of coming down on me. So I feel like it’s been a little bit later than other people where they’re like, “Oh, I love nature and I’ve been outside.” But it took me some time, and I also think it’s just, you find yourself whenever you are met with adversity. So I would say in my early twenties is when I found my love for nature.

Erniko Brown: Cool. I’ll go next. So for me, I’m a country girl. I come from the country, so the earth has been my playground my entire life, from gardening to farming, to just being out in nature. I come from a very rural area, so there wasn’t a lot of economic buildup there. And so if you wanted to do something outside of watching The Price Is Right, you had to go outside. And the way that they used to say it is don’t come back in the house until the street lights come on. So my love of nature came out of just not really knowing that there was a love for it and being in the space and constantly exploring it.

Kimala Luna: Yeah. I also grew up in a rural area, and so I spent a lot of time outside, but really I feel like the first time I felt a deep connection was there was the tree in my backyard that had a branch just low enough for me to be able to lift myself up on it when I was really small. And I just developed this friendship with this one tree, and it felt really real to me. Because I was a kid, I could pretend that it was more, I don’t know, animated than it actually was, but it still feels like a real friendship.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Yeah. I definitely relate to a lot of those answers. And then I guess going off of Elizabeth’s answer, do you have a go-to place in nature where you can find peace and healing, and how does nature emotionally affect you in times of conflict and adversity?

Elizabeth Lashay: I believe I have found my love of hiking, and so anywhere that gives me a different perspective, anywhere where I can hike and kind of be above the earth and overlook some things in the mountains. That’s a place of solitude for me. And I again want to follow up what I said earlier is that it has this natural healing power of centering and grounding, listening to the wind and analyzing the smell and getting in touch with all of your senses while just being in the present and in the moment is such a beautiful thing. So I would say anywhere where there’s a hike and I can overlook a beautiful landscape.

Kimala Luna: I love that. I love that answer. I really liked what you said earlier too, Liz, about the forest as a space of healing, and then going in to illustrate all the things that you tune you in. I think that’s cool.

Elizabeth Lashay: Yeah.

Erniko Brown: I mean, for me, I would definitely say anywhere that there is a lake, a waterfall, or a mountain. Waterfalls are beautiful, and they seem so cleansing of the things that you’re going through. I know for me when I’m just having a hard time, just to hear the water or hearing animals out in nature, and like Liz up in the mountains, I always say that’s breathing a different type of air and it’s like clearer thinking, a different type of smell, a different type of area to bring about something different in your life, something beautiful. So anytime connecting with something beautiful brings about a different perspective in the things that you’re doing.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Was there a moment when you realized the urgency of the climate crisis and became determined to get involved with the climate justice movement?

Erniko Brown: I know for me being in a rural area, as I stated previously, we’re not always at the table. And so when I had an opportunity to be at the table, to be a part of things, I definitely took those opportunities because I don’t carry the weight of myself; I carry the weight of my community. And so having them at the table, thinking about not only myself or the elders in my community, but the people, the young people in the futures and how this is going to affect them, and understanding that we have to be stewards, and when that opportunity presents itself, definitely step up to the plate, and so that’s what I’ve been doing.

Elizabeth Lashay: Mm-hmm (affirmative). I think for me, again, I’ve always been on this journey of fighting for justice and especially racial inequality and justice disparities, and wanting to tackle all of the systems that impact racial discrimination and injustice. But it wasn’t until I was asked to host the annual Woods and Wilds Festival that is put on by Dogwood Alliance that I really had to analyze all the ways in which I just didn’t know what I didn’t know. And I took time to research before stepping into the role of hosting, and I started realizing it really is intertwining any injustice, and so it’s not siloed. It’s not a one-off that environmental justice is separate from anything else. And so that’s really where I started my journey was a few years ago through Dogwood Alliance, and then since then, I’ve been really excited to continue to learn, and learn from other people, and learn from my cohosts, and listen, and just see how everything is interconnected.

Kimala Luna: Yeah. I’ve always wanted to be of value in the world. So I think I’ve always been driven to areas that I could be of service, but I think the urgency piece also didn’t really hit home until a few years ago. It was like 2017. I went to this climate action conference in New York and scientist after scientist got up on stage, letting us know that we had 20 years left as a species, which was really a heavy, heavy, heavy thought. And so looking at that and looking at all of the things that needed to be done that hadn’t been done since the 80s, when they originally knew that our planet was warming, really drove it home. And then after that, it was just looking at, like Liz was saying, all the systemic ways that injustice has been perpetuated from the beginning, it’s a part of the genesis of our nation, just made it all real.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Wow. Yeah, those are incredible answers. And then are there any leaders that are most inspirational to your work?

Kimala Luna: I get a lot of inspiration from the people I work closest with. So I would say that Erniko and Liz are some of the people that I feel like really guide my work, and a lot of people that I work with I feel like are just doing incredible stuff that you don’t hear about. It’s like, we hear about people, major players in the climate movement and they’re doing beautiful stuff, but there’s so many people on the ground moving things every day that I feel like all deserve so much recognition.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Yeah. That’s very true. I definitely agree with that.

Elizabeth Lashay: And I want to follow that too. There’s so many people… Today I went to a meeting in the South Side garden, and then I was able to look at the individuals who are cooking the vegetables from the garden and how it’s just something that happens, and we don’t recognize people that make things happen. So I want to follow what Kimala had said because that’s such a beautiful thing is we tend to forget. So I’m constantly inspired. I’m inspired and empowered by younger individuals and elders and being able to be a thought partner in things.

Erniko Brown: Yeah, and I’ll just follow them too. And definitely what Slay said about the younger generation. I’m inspired that I have this opportunity, this very unique opportunity to be sitting at the table with so many people and doing the things that they will be doing. So I was inspired by them because I heard a younger podcast and I’m like, well, what if we pull this up, create a podcast around this, and have these conversations. The movement, the Black Lives Matter movement, just all the movements, and for me going home, and I see people who are 65, 70 still out in the garden, still talking about the trees and still reminiscing on those old stories about how things used to be simple in life. So just gathering information and inspiration from them and being able to tie that into the work that I do constantly keeps me motivated and constantly keeps me moving in this work. So understanding that this movement is not just for myself. This movement that has been created is for so many people from so many different places, and everything that we do is intersectional, and every way that we’re working in part of it is intentional. So that’s what pulls me in every time.

Kimala Luna: And I just want to say it, because I don’t think it was ever even clearly stated that Erniko serves as commissioner, and Liz is the founder of a media group called SlaytheMic, and these are in addition to their full-time jobs, and that’s just a fraction of what they’re up to every day. I just wanted to make sure that our listeners knew those details.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Yeah, that’s amazing. Thank you. And then as hosts of this podcast, what is the most meaningful thing that you have heard by witnessing all of the episodes?

Erniko Brown: Oh man. Listen, I will say if you have not listened to the podcast, there are so many different jewels that are here, so many things that have been said from so many amazing people, and it’s various different perspectives on nature, on things that are going on in the world. And for me, I can’t put one against the other. It’s all been amazing. I can’t choose, but Slay might have something she wants to say.

Elizabeth Lashay: No, I think that’s a really difficult question because we’ve interviewed so many people, and every person has a unique story that is the puzzle piece to this podcast and are all equally important insight. Just going back onto being inspired, listening to all these stories of how people found their voice, and where it came from, and when they fell in love with the earth, and what is the action they’re taking to make this world a better place. I simply can’t choose, but I am constantly inspired and have so many lessons that I have learned from our listening sessions, our podcast.

Kimala Luna: I agree. I will say, I think it was the very first podcast we had was with Thomas RaShad Easley, who is also a musical artist and a poet. And that conversation, there are certain conversations… I mean, they’re all just so, like Erniko and Liz were saying, they’re so sparky, and you have these moments where you’re just resonating, but that first one was like, oh man. It was so inspiring to feel like we maybe had something really cool here, just listening to him talk. And we use his poetry as the intro of our podcast. And it just, it felt like such a good way to begin. And then since then, it’s just stayed that good, and that’s been really wonderful.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Yeah. That’s incredible. I really enjoyed listening to that episode. And the next question, what motivates you each personally?

Erniko Brown: I’ll jump in. For me, as I stated, just having the opportunities that I’m privy to motivate me, knowing that there is a generation behind me who has not tapped into environmental stuff, and meeting them where they are as far as podcasts, and making things relatable to them, and making sure that they see this as a pathway and not a project, and bringing about change for them in the ability to show them that they can be change agents just as we are, motivates me each and every day, because there are so many people out here scrambling in the world has changed, but as the world changes, we definitely can offer up this solution to them and these spaces for them. That’s how I’m motivated.

Elizabeth Lashay: I think I’m motivated because I’m constantly wanting to find ways in which we can amplify voices. And I believe the more that we amplify voices, the more perspectives and stories we’ll have and the better that we’ll be because of those stories. And so I’m motivated because the power of space, time, and voice is something that’s unmatched and that I have really taken for granted over the years but have learned the importance now. And so I’m constantly motivated by just hearing others.

Kimala Luna: I would say collaboration motivates me the most because if it goes well, it’s really inspiring and it’s transformational for the community. And if it goes badly, it’s really humbling and transformational for yourself. And I think that there’s so much power in connecting to others, and coming at things from a different perspective, and putting a bunch of brains on it. So that’s what motivates me.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Wow. Is there a project or program that you have each worked on at your respective organizations that has been most impactful for you?

Elizabeth Lashay: I can go. I definitely know that I not only have a radio show, but as we’re building this multimedia company, I am really excited to just continue to see where does the build-out go, learning new things about myself and what does strength look like? And also what does my leadership look like? And refining and defining myself. So working on the project of SlaytheMic and WBMU Jams, which is a digital radio station. And the call letters have a deep historic meaning, and those call letters are Where Black Means Unity. And so it aligns with my mission, and I am also just excited to have a multimedia company where we’re very intentionally placing people into spaces to enhance businesses for other people in our area. So I’m just excited about seeing how I grow and help others grow along with it.

Erniko Brown: I definitely feel Slay, what she said, the strength, and the leadership piece. I have several different projects I’m working on, especially if I haven’t grown, it’s pushing me to grow in my capacity of being a commissioner. Being an elected official, you understand that there are certain ways you need to present yourself. So the formalities and stuff, I want people to be able to see it’s a normal thing to be at the table, but you also have to have certain etiquette within the leadership. And in my capacity as the state chair for environmental climate justice on behalf of the NAACP, I’m learning all of the different projects and how the work is never done, and there’s always something to be done in your community. Then at Dogwood, being the Regional Partnership Engagement Manager, I’m always in community with Black people, and me being a Black person, being able to offer opportunities and resources to communities that are impacted and doing that work on behalf of those communities really helped me grow in the work that I’m doing. And being a chief of staff for YDSC, which is Young Democrats of South Carolina, being in that leadership role and making sure that my people are doing what they need to do on behalf of the communities that we’re serving definitely stretches me. So I would say all of those push me to leadership, push me to grow, push me to be the best that I can be. Not not only for myself, but for my community and the young people that are looking toward me for guidance.

Kimala Luna: Yeah, I would say we were doing this tour across the south called the Justice First tour. And I was doing an event under that and for the Asheville stop and was collaborating with Southside. And that’s how I met Liz. And I learned so much from that project about my local community and that I really hadn’t spent that much time at the Southside Community Center before that. And I was really inspired by all the work being done there. So if you’re tuning in, and you’re a local, and you’re in Asheville, I really recommend checking them out. Liz was talking about the garden earlier. Yeah.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Those are all incredible projects that you’ve all been working on. I was wondering, is there a particular song or genre of music that you feel drawn to when you are in nature?

Elizabeth Lashay: I love Indie Arie. There’s two songs, and one song is called, Closer, and I cannot remember the artist’s name. And then there is Beautiful by India Arie. And so it feels very freeing and again, tapping into all of those senses. Those two songs definitely motivate and inspire me.

Kimala Luna: I love Indie Arie. Video was always my favorite.

Elizabeth Lashay: Ooh, yeah.

Erniko Brown: For me, I think it’s Maze featuring Frankie Beverly, We Are One. That is definitely the song I’m just really tapped into. It’s beautiful. It’s talking about unification, and then there’s Marvin Gaye, I think it was The Ecology, I think it is. Oh man, and Mercy Mercy Me. So those are three songs, Marvin Gaye and Frankie Beverly featuring Maze.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Amazing. Well, it has been wonderful listening to all of your answers, and I just wanted to open up a dialogue and ask if you had any reflections or thoughts about your time hosting this podcast.

Kimala Luna: I just love it. It’s my favorite thing ever.

Erniko Brown: I’ll jump in, and I’ll say it’s been super exciting because I never did a podcast before. I love people and that’s for real. So to listen to the podcast, listen to the individual stories, listen to their reasons as to why they’re doing what they’re doing, continues to inspire me, and reaching out beyond ourselves and seeing other people authentically in the work that they’re doing and them being the person that they are, has been a lot of inspiration to keep me grounded in the work that I do. And being here with Kimala and Slay, it’s been absolutely wonderful. I feel like, hey, we need to take this show on the road.

Kimala Luna: Yeah.

Erniko Brown: Yeah. I just love doing it. And apart from the work that I do, I love the work that I do, but being able to come to this space, spend this time with these individuals has been absolutely amazing for me.

Elizabeth Lashay: Yeah, I think I follow everything of what both of you all have already said, but I think there’s so much laughter and so much beauty and just again, the power of space and slowing down because my days are constantly busy, busy, busy, busy, and taking time to listen to other people is really healing for me. So I’ve loved it, and I’ve enjoyed it.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Yeah. That’s amazing to hear. And I appreciate the work that you all do in highlighting the people who are doing the work on the ground and all of the important things that are going on.

Kimala Luna: Thank you, Chaya. What’s your favorite thing about the podcast?

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Well, I really love environmental art. And so I’ve loved hearing all of the different kinds of art that people do and where they get their inspiration from. So I think that’s been my favorite part.

Kimala Luna: Yay. Well, this has been wonderful. Anything else guys?

Erniko Brown: No, I just think I want to thank Chaya for being here today and interviewing us because it’s always us interviewing somebody, but who’s checking the checker? So thank you Chaya for checking us. Great.

Elizabeth Lashay: Yes, yes, yes. I love it.

Chaya Brennan Agarwal: Yes. Thank you for having me. I really enjoyed it.

Kimala Luna: Yes. And for those who are watching this or listening to this, just kidding, listening to this for the first time, please be sure to check out all of our other episodes, and follow and like, and subscribe. It really keeps it going.

 

In Memoriam of Luis “Doc” Contreras

On Jun 25, 2021, Arkansas, Southern forests, and the planet lost one of their true heroes. Luis “Doc” Contreras was a climate champion, a creative campaigner, a spirited activist, and a lover of humanity and every dog he ever met. He passed away in Eureka Springs, Arkansas at the age of 71.

Luis Doc Contreras and rescue dogs

Luis “Doc” Contreras and his rescue pups

I first met Doc, who held a PhD from Georgia Tech for Statistical Engineering, when he called me out of the blue to talk about a gigantic paper mill that a foreign company with a bad reputation wanted to build in Arkansas. Of course, the state government invited them in and threw lots of money at them to make sure they built the first new paper mill in the South in decades.

It was a fight against impossible odds and no one was stepping up to try and stop it – except of course Doc.

Luis Doc Contreras public hearing Arkansas

Luis “Doc” Contreras speaking truth to power at a public hearing in Arkansas.

Every time the company applied for a new permit or the state spent more money to entice the company, Doc was there with evidence and passion and a never ending fountain of spirit to oppose this mill. Every time the Governor or Representative Bruce Westerman, the only professional forester in Congress, came out to cheer for the facility, Doc was there with a funny, insightful, and logical response.

He wrote countless letters and editorials for the local paper in Eureka Springs, he spent countless hours doing research on permits, money trails, corporate malfeasance, alternative solutions, and climate impacts to show why this was a bad thing for the people and forests of the state.

Doc was a lone voice in the wilderness. Nothing ever shook him or made him quit.

Doc’s tireless work was rewarded when the company, who had spent years trying to make it happen, finally gave up. The forests and people of Arkansas breathed a sigh of relief. At that point he could’ve rode off into the sunset, but not Doc. Instead he turned his sights on the many pellet mills proposed for the state. From Zilkha to Highland Pellets to the latest proposal from Drax, he never quit. He was the best kind of activist, and I absolutely loved working with him.

Luis Contreras Standing Rock

Luis “Doc” Contreras and Hercules stand with Standing Rock

Zilkha disappeared, Highland struggled to make its business profitable, and Drax was just starting to get nervous. I spoke to Doc about three days before his passing, and he was as passionate as ever. He had made inroads with the agencies and had a strategy to stop this big, bad British company. I believe his plan can still work as long as we can all channel our inner Doc and fight for our forests, frontline communities, and our planet.

The entire Dogwood Alliance staff mourns the loss of one of our own.

Our hearts are with his wife Crystal, his nine rescue dogs, and his extended family. It was such an honor and a privilege to work with Doc. He was a real treasure for Arkansas and will be sorely missed. His spirit and passion live on in every single climate activist, lover of forests, and all who laugh in the face of insurmountable odds. You’ll be missed Doc.

When Great Trees Fall by Maya Angelou

community-roots-logo-climate-bill-of-rightsDogwood Alliance is in support of the Community Roots Climate Bill of Rights for Asheville, NC.

We thank our good friends at Community Roots for their beautiful work and vision.

We need true climate justice in North Carolina.

The Community Climate Bill of Rights is paradigm-shifting local level legislation.

It asserts our Rights for local self-governance over those of corporations to make a profit – a crucial step in building sustainable communities.

We seek to establish our Rights for local self-governance and a healthy climate, prohibiting the building of new fossil fuel infrastructure, and requiring the City of Asheville to create and implement a bolder Transition Plan to get us to 100% renewable energy by 2030.

It will also establish the RIGHTS OF NATURE in Asheville

Read the full Climate Bill of Rights here.

Guest Post by Robby Phillips

In June, South Carolina’s Department of Health and Environmental Control (DHEC) held a routine public hearing about a proposed permit for a wood pellet facility that would grind wood into pellets in a process that emits dangerous pollution and then ship those pellets overseas to be burned for biomass fuel. There was nothing routine, though, about the powerful story that unfolded. Over a dozen members of the Effingham, SC community, near where the facility is slated to be built, pleaded with DHEC to deny the permit. One woman spoke of losing her daughter to pollution-fueled respiratory illness. Another person spoke of his family’s generational ties to the area and how each subsequent generation has endured new forms of exploitation and environmental degradation. Chief Parr of the Pee Dee Indian Tribe remarked that his people have never relented in the fight to protect their forests and their land, but moneyed interests seem to always win.

The hearing told a story of the fight for environmental justice and of a larger fight for this South Carolina community to have their voices heard.

south-carolina-organizer-loretta-slater

South Carolina community organizer Loretta Slater stands among solar panels.

Effingham, South Carolina’s population is made up of a high proportion of people of color who live below the poverty line and have been disproportionately affected by COVID-19.

This is true of many communities throughout the South where environmentally destructive wood pellet facilities are sited. These communities have rallied time and time again against these projects and fought to protect their land, water, and health, but as Chief Parr alluded to, those in power are often deferential to supposed economic interests more than those of health and environment, despite all three issues being deeply interlinked.

The permit in question would allow Effingham Pellets LLC to build a new wood pellet production plant. They would use shavings from a timber mill about a mile away from the proposed site to produce upwards of 43,000 metric tons of wood pellets each year, mostly to be shipped internationally for burning as an electricity and heat source. This is only one of many such facilities that have been proposed and built throughout the Southeast which Dogwood has fought against.

south-carolina-pee-dee-tribe-chief-parr

Chief Parr of the Pee Dee Tribe calls for community-led solutions to climate change.

Industry beneficiaries, including one who read a carefully worded statement in favor of the permit at the hearing, claim that using biomass fuel sources like wood pellets will help reduce emissions by replacing fossil fuels, while also benefiting the economy. Climate science is often misconstrued or selectively used to support this false argument. The facility proposed in Effingham would produce carbon dioxide emissions equivalent to over 18,000 additional cars on the road each year, when accounting for the production and eventual burning of these pellets. Further, the pellets are not addressing an energy need in the US or even economically benefiting more than a handful of people.

Most of the product will be exported, and the facility will only create 10 jobs at most for the surrounding South Carolina community.

This is not a worthwhile tradeoff for polluted air and worsening the climate crisis.

In addition to the harm that facilities like these inflict upon surrounding communities, they also squander the little time we have to divert the worst of the climate crisis. I’m 20 years old, and my youth has been defined by wildfires, worsening hurricanes, and dire warnings about our need to cut global emissions in half by 2030. Already this summer, we’ve seen record high temperatures in the Pacific Northwest, flooding in the Midwest and South, and literal fires in the ocean as pipelines leak. It is climate denialism to forge ahead on new facilities that produce carbon-intensive fuel. Our futures are at stake—youth like myself and frontline communities like those in Effingham are making our call loud and clear:

We deserve to have a healthy future with truly clean energy.

south-carolina-community-fights-pellet-mill-wetlandAll of our economies, health, and futures rely on rapidly creating a world powered by clean, renewable energy in which we protect our air and water. Our public institutions and officials have an obligation to make this transition their utmost priority. It’s certainly true for an agency whose very purpose is protecting our health and environment like DHEC.

DHEC opened the public hearing by explaining what PM, VOC, and other pollutant levels are considered acceptable; the air permit for the facility claims that they will release pollutants below this threshold of acceptability. What if, instead, we did not accept any amount of pollution being discharged into our communities against the will of the people? What if we reject industries that exacerbate and even cause respiratory illnesses and generally lead to a decline in quality of life? To truly build a just world and prioritize our health and environment, we must utilize the tools and technology we have to listen to the concerns and needs of our most vulnerable. It’s imperative that we create clean and green energy for all. Our futures depend on it.


Robby Phillips is a rising Junior at Duke University, where he is majoring in Public Policy and minoring in Environmental Science & Policy and History. He is passionate about organizing in politics and for environmental justice. He loves being outdoors, whether it be swimming, hiking, or just hanging out on a nice day with friends or family.

Support Us

Act Now

What’s the most effective way to protect Southern forests? Get involved! We make it easy for you to make a difference.

Join the Movement

Unite with the forests & communities of the South. Be part of the forests, climate, and justice solution.